contact@cdaqi.com 
Why LLMs Are Probabilistic & Why Answers May Differ in Agent Workflows
Large Language Models (LLMs) have transformed how we interact with machines, enabling natural conversations, creative writing, and advanced reasoning. However, a key aspect of their behavior often surprises users: LLMs are fundamentally probabilistic. This means that even when asked the same question twice, an LLM may produce different answers. Let’s explore why this happens and what it means for agent workflows.
The Probabilistic Core of LLMs
At their heart, LLMs are not databases that retrieve fixed facts, but generative models that predict the next word (or token) in a sequence based on probability distributions learned from vast amounts of text data. Here’s how it works:
- When given a prompt, the model calculates the probability of every possible next word.
- It then selects the next word based on these probabilities, not by following a fixed rule.
- This process repeats, building a response word by word, each time sampling from a probability distribution.
For example, if prompted with “The capital of France is”, the model might assign a very high probability to “Paris”, but could also generate “Paris, the city of lights” or even something less expected, depending on the context and settings.
Why Answers May Differ
There are several reasons why the same prompt may produce different outputs:
- Randomness in Sampling: Each response is generated by sampling from a probability distribution. Slight changes in parameters like “temperature” can lead to different outputs.
- Prompt and Context Sensitivity: Small wording or context changes shift probability estimates, producing different answers.
- No Built-in Fact-Checking: LLMs don’t verify facts; they generate what’s most probable, which can lead to hallucinations.
- Evolving Internal State: In agent workflows, conversation history and tool outputs change the prompt context at each step, leading to varied answers.
Practical Scenario in Agent Workflows
Imagine an agent that first tries to answer a user’s question directly, then consults a knowledge base if needed. The LLM might give one answer in the first step and a different answer after retrieving new context — even if the question is repeated — because the agent’s state and prompt context have changed.
Embracing Probabilistic Outputs
The probabilistic nature of LLMs is not a flaw, but a feature. It allows for creativity, adaptability, and nuanced language generation. However, it also means that:
- Consistency is not guaranteed unless randomness is constrained (e.g., temperature = 0).
- Agent designers must carefully manage state and context for reliable outputs.
- Users should understand that LLMs generate likely responses, not definitive facts.
In summary: LLMs are probabilistic because they generate each word based on learned likelihoods, not fixed rules. In agent workflows, this means answers may differ across steps or runs due to changes in context, prompt, and inherent randomness. Understanding this is key to designing robust, trustworthy AI systems.
